A Sharp Agile Stand-up
Updated: Sep 4, 2023
By David Rose
The daily standup is the centerpiece of most agile methodologies for running teams. Whether you prefer the extra structure of SCRUM or you are more of a KANBAN purest you will be very familiar with the daily standup meeting. This meeting pre dates many of these methodologies as a way of staying on top of a group as they work day to day, but agile looks to give this meeting a new lease of life.

Disclaimer: There are many different styles of running a meeting, but I am going to share with you here what has worked well for me over many years of conducting and observing successful standups.
The Basics:
The Daily Standup should be as brief as possible to convey the most important information from each individual in the team to the rest of the team and to the person running the meeting / taking the notes. It is possible to have a productive standup with as many as 15 people if you stay disciplined and keep everybody on track by creating and policing some rules and focusing on the "Core Questions"

Focus on these Core questions:
What did you do yesterday?
What are you doing today?
Any Blockers?
These questions should be answered clearly and briefly by each team member in a round robin. Everyone should stay in the meeting until all participants have completed their Core questions.
This meeting is not for solutioning a problem. It is ok to have a really short back and forth conversation on a simple blocker, like requiring access be granted to a server or for the individual to ask the team if anyone has experience of a particular topic that they are about to address etc. with the intension of agreeing to meet outside of the meeting for a catchup. These interactions should however be the exception and for the majority of this meeting we should stay on the core questions and as businesslike as possible in getting through them.
Question 1 and 2, what was done yesterday and what will be done today allows an opportunity for minor steers by the leaders in the group should the individual be going off track. If there is a serious issue or a need for a conversation of say longer than 60 seconds, then a breakout meeting or an individual follow up should be recoded in the minutes and the meeting should continue to the next question or person in the round robin.
Question 3. Any Blockers? is designed to flush out problems, but the purpose of this meeting is not to solve the blockers, that should be done by follow up actions, or in a break out session.
If the need arises for say a 5 minute or longer conversation with a member of the team, this should become a break out session at the end of the standup with only the people required to facilitate a good meeting attending, thus freeing up everyone else to get on with their work. Often these breakout session will be queued up and dealt with one by one in an order that frees the most people up as efficiently as possible.
Avoid Conflict within the standup
Remember this meeting is not a got-ya session. We do not want conflict to upset the rhythm of our standup, nor do we want people to feel on edge or defensive during this call as that would be a barrier to good communication and would result in individuals being stressed every day - usually at the start of their day.
As a leader in the standup we are looking for certain red and amber flags :
Someone is having an issue! (Help should be provided)
Someone is performing very well! (Praise / recognition should be given, in real time and later)
Someone is not pulling their weight on a regular basis! (This needs addressing after the call)
Are some team members helping others! (A good thing, worth considering the impact this has on the person helping others throughput of work and making allowances for same, perhaps a conversation after the call to establish the impact etc.)
Are any team members taking advantage of others! (We want everyone performant, do we need to take action here? do some of the team need training?)
Have we got the right tasks assigned to the right people! (Some people may not be able to ever complete some tasks in highly technical teams.)
Remember keep the meeting moving, if someone gives unsatisfactory answers to the core questions, ask them for an individual break out session after the meeting and address the issues one on one with the person. If you need to involve another member of the team in the conversation that is ok too, just bring the minimum number of people you feel you need to solve the problem.
Police the meeting:
For any meeting being on time and expecting others to be on time is a must. Everyone has a lot of work to do and when we make a time for collaboration like a standup we must ensure that it starts on time. On time is within 5 mins of the allotted time. Anyone falling outside of this allotted time should be called out and asked to be on time.
People can have genuine reasons to be late for a standup, or to want to give their report and then leave the call, but they should communicate their expected late arrival to the meeting invite or in the meeting chat ahead of time and should understand that this must be the exception not the rule.
The standup is not a meeting purely for the team to communicate with the SCRUM Master or Project manager its also an opportunity for the team to help each other. Its the one time of the day where you get to hear what others are doing and if you have expertise in a given area perhaps some collaboration will be possible. Often at the end of the call the leaders on the call will share messages to the whole team as a unit.
Remind People of the meetings importance - It may be helpful to articulate why we need great meeting etiquette and how this meeting is designed to be as efficient as possible for everyone.
Share Clear Notes - Offer to amend them if any part of the notes are in-accurate (Use the notes tomorrow to keep track of the what people did yesterday question)
Follow up on Notes
Follow up on yesterdays notes with each individual once they have completed the core questions. Only ask follow ups if there is a need, if everything is clear and todays notes flow correctly from yesterdays just move on, its all about efficiency in this meeting. Remember, you can ask the individual to give you bullet points outlining what they have reported rather than asking the person to repeat their answers, this is also a good idea if there is a bad connection and oral communication is difficult.
Be Kind and Consistent
This meeting is every day, and so you can set the tone here for how the team treat each other. No high performance team operates on low morale, so be conscious that people may struggle on any given day, always keep the bigger picture in mind. Remember, even really high performing individuals will not be able to go at the same speed every day and so have realistic expectations and avoid micro management.
Note: With SCRUM we only evaluate the team and the individual on the basis of the 2 week sprint and not on one days work.
Don't be a push over either, if you have a consistent issue with an individual, who is not giving good daily reports, its very important that you address this with the person. The whole team will know what is happening anyway from the daily reports and if not handled the morale of the group can suffer. Hold everyone to an appropriately high standard for their skill level.
In summary, be very deliberate in your policing of the daily standup. Keep the meeting very focused on the three core questions. Take great notes and ensure you keep the teams morale high, while also addressing problems in break out meetings and one on one catchups.
Share the Chair- Once you have the meeting running consistently well and on time, its a great idea to share the chair of the meeting with first the leaders of the group and later with all other participants in a round robin day by day.
You can still steer the call as needed if you are present, but by having each member of the team run the meeting in the style you have established. Team members show more empathy and buy in when they have to sit in the chair themselves sometimes. There are many other benefits to this approach, I will let you discover them yourself! Happy hunting!
Please check out my other blog posts and watch out for more in the future.


Comments